A couple of weeks ago the 2016 Student Experience Survey (SES) National Report was released – affectionately known as QILT (or Quality Indicators in Learning and Teaching).
Graduation Autumn 2017 – Parramatta Campus
The SES provides a “national architecture for collecting feedback on key facets of the higher education student experience” and measures five aspects of the student experience:
- Skills Development,
- Learner Engagement,
- Teaching Quality,
- Student Support, and
- Learning Resources.
The report always makes interesting reading for individual universities: which improved, which declined and which seem to be resting on their past achievements.
Overall, it is good news for the universities across Australia and confirms the position of the Australian sector as one of the best in the world. This is recognised internationally with education being Australia’s third largest export – you would not recognise it given the low profile it is often given by our national decision-makers.
But what we should also note is the steady 18 percent that consider leaving university: almost 1 in 5 – a concerning statistic indeed.
I think it is a valuable survey and support it, but it fails to tell us: ‘what makes for a good university experience?’
As the Dean of Graduate Studies at Western Sydney University, there are two areas that tend to occupy my mind: The first is the well-being of the PhD candidates that are part of my university and I feel responsible for; and, the second is the completion rates of these candidates knowing that most of them obsess over this.
In my work, the factors that I have attempted influence which assist students are as follows:
- The doctoral training program;
- The research environment establishing a cohort identity;
- The role of PhD supervisors – ensuring they are adequately trained and understand their obligations;
- The different cultural and social contexts of the candidates; and,
- Providing an environment where students feel supported and, as I have written before, understand ‘how to survive‘.
It has been over 18 months since I was appointed the Dean of Western Sydney University’s Graduate Research School. It is a job that I really do love.
But is also a job that can be heartbreaking, as I have seen good students drop out – both within my university and from other institutions. Many students come and see me for advice and I have been keeping a collection of tips I have learnt based on successful candidates and outstanding supervisors. So here they are… and in no particular order…
- Build networks: this is not just about networking that opens opportunities, but about building supportive structures around you to help you through all those challenging times. Use your networks to organise writing circles, boot-camps, give each other feedback and a shoulder to lean on when things are stressful.
- Collaborate, collaborate, collaborate: Always look for people to work with – it is more fun, less isolating and you learn new skills! It is also part of building networks and support structures.
- Its more than just research: You can be the best researcher in the world but if what you write sits on a bookshelf somewhere, what is the point? Practice your communication, be a good writer, learn how to translate your research. Increasingly funders ask questions about ‘impact’ and ‘engagement’ – and as such, ‘citations’ play less of a role!
- Accept the fact that you are now an academic: When you begin a higher degree by research (HDR) you are part of the faculty – no longer a student! As such, you should play an active part with your research group, your School and your University. Further, the research culture and reputation of the University will be reflective of you… Consequently, get ready for both the good and bad about academia!
- Take care and enjoy yourself: Seriously folks, but make sure that you eat, sleep, shower, plan breaks and down time, spend time with loved ones and never forget to showers. Put pressure on yourself but never obsess over the university. This is important because academia tends to exploit your passions: so you get into it, volunteer for things and never take are of yourself. This is the fastest route to burn out! So be passionate – but ensure that is measured with a sense of self care.
- Avoid university and interpersonal politics: It is pointless, exhausting and only pursued by those with small minds (no matter how many publications they have) and big egos. Enough said! Continue reading
Lecturing about race and racism is one of the most challenging lectures I do. This is because I do not simply talk about these issues in theory, but discuss how they play out in our everyday lives: including how I wrestle with my own prejudices.
I have always tried to confront my own inner thoughts and feelings. As part of this, I co-wrote a paper about my own prejudices in 2008 titled ‘Racists Like Us…‘. It was a difficult paper to write and at the time I received a number of abusive emails – and once during a presentation a couple of people walked out.
The argument of the paper is that we all carry prejudices – particularly when we find ourselves in privileged positions – and these are learnt as we progress through life. The instincts we develop are there and we should be brave enough to admit it: for only we are willing to admit these can we confront them.
I had almost forgotten I had written this paper until someone retweeted it stating that it remains relevant almost 10 years later particularly in the current political context. I just re-read it and though there are parts that still make me feel uncomfortable, I really do think it is worthy of discussion.
I am a supporter of the Race Discrimination Act and have argued here that we should protect Section 18C – something I have discussed in a Sociologic podcast. But this does not mean we cannot have difficult and complex conversations – at home, with friends, in the classroom and in the media. These need to remain respectful and we need to remain cognisant of the fact that the feelings of others should always be acknowledged and protected as best as we can.
Over the last few days I have been reflecting on the need to review the graduates attributes that are at the centre of the Citizen Scholar program that I have been developing with colleagues over the last few years. The question is whether universities have the ability to continue to evolve at the pace required to ensure the needs of our students and society is met.
It was with this in mind that I came to read a speech by Australia’s Chief Scientist, Dr Alan Finkel, at the TEQSA conference titled Red Tape or Gift Wrap: Regulation for exceptional tertiary institutions. I must say I am a big fan of the Chief Scientist and very much like listening to what he has to say.
In the speech, Dr Finkel reminds us that regulation should not be something we should fear, but if established correctly, can set an environment of engagement, collaboration as well as competition.
It all sounds straightforward but as someone involved in implementing some of the TEQSA requirements, it is always easy to simply look at regulation as a burden.
This week I had the pleasure of launching an exhibition of the work of Lee Hong. Lee is an Australian-Chinese artists who studied at the Central Academy of Art in Beijing. I find Lee’s art incredibly insightful. Below is the calatlogue essay I wrote.
According to Existential philosophers such as Soren Kierkegaard, we as individuals are responsible for creating a life with meaning. In a world that is absurd, unfair, irrational and often meaningless, it is one reason that we live with a sense of ongoing anxiety.
We have to traverse a complex world and are constantly confronted with decisions that may lead us into a charmed life or one of toil.
Kierkegaard describes this sensation in the following way: “Standing on a cliff, a sense of disorientation and confusion cloud you. Not only are you afraid of falling, you also fear succumbing to the impulse of throwing yourself off. Nothing is holding you back. Dread, anxiety and anguish rise to the surface.”
This week I delivered the opening keynote at the annual conference of universities that are overseen by the Ministry of Religious Affairs (MoRA) in Indonesia.
Though not an expert in Islamic Studies or religion, I was asked to attend to speak about the role of universities in the contemporary world – with a specific focus on the universities in the MoRA network.
It was an amazing experience and one that I was humbled to be part of. Below is a copy of my keynote presentation…
I want to begin my short presentation with a simple statement: the contribution of Indonesian Islam to Western Civilisation has never been more important. In fact, my argument is that the world is at a crossroad – arriving here by hawks that see religion as a way of manufacturing – and I emphasise this word ‘manufacturing’ – a clash of civilisations for political gain.
As the world stands at this crossroad, Indonesian Islam has the opportunity to heal the rupture between the East and the West – to build bridges that others have attempted to break down.
Last week Western Sydney University had its September graduations. It is always an important event for those graduating, their families and also the university – something that it true for all universities.
It is an event that the University takes seriously – and is always well attended by senior management and staff…
But last week was particularly special…
After walking on to the stage, the first part of any graduations ceremony is the national anthem. Whenever I take part in singing the national anthem, I always take a moment to reflect on the hopes of our nation: thinking to myself, ‘what would Australia look like at its best?’
It was a strange day because the night before, Senator Pauline Hanson had delivered her second maiden speech. You know the one – and there is no link required… it does not need any more hits on youtube.
Recently I was asked to curate an exhibition of Ink Wash Paintings at the Chinese Culture Centre. The work was launched in August 2016.
As the curator, I also wrote the essay titled Mutualism: a connection across worlds which I have reproduced below.
The exhibition, focussing on ink, reminded me how artists are connected across time and space by their method, tools and style.
I hope you enjoy the essay:
Mutualism: a connection across worlds
Mutualism is the way two organisms from different species come to exist in a relationship. In this relationship, there is a type of balance as each separate organism benefits in the actions, activities and engagement of the other. It is not just cooperation but moves beyond this – it is a symbiotic relationship in which these organisms thrive from the others actions.
We can contrast this with a competitive environment where the actions of one group of organisms undermines, diminishes, weakens or even kills off another species.